<br /> Trademark Issues with Debian’s packaging of Mozilla – Debian Planet

Welcome to Debian Planet

News for Debian. Stuff that *really* matters


Debian Planet is hosted by Bluelinux Internet Services Ltd. Offering a special discounted rate for Free and Open Source software community members.

Buy your Debian merchandise at DebianShop.com.

These are important Debian sites one should not be without!

  • Official Debian site
  • Package search
  • Mailing list archives
  • Bug reports
  • Debian on CD
  • Debian Weekly News — excellent news source!
  • Unofficial APT sources

  • Developers’ Corner
  • Community
    Need help? You’re not alone on this planet.

  • Planet Debian
  • debianHELP
    (User support site)

  • Debian Administration
    (SysAdmin resources)

  • Debian International
  • DebianForum.de

  • DebianForum.dk

  • EsDebian

  • DebianWorld

  • Debian-Fr

  • MaximumDebian

  • DebianItalia
  • DebianUsers

  • Debian-BR

  • DebianHOWTO

  • Russian Debian (Русский)
  • Debian-JP
  • Debian Suisse
  • Contribute
    Got that latest or greatest scoop? Perhaps you have some important news for the Debian community? Submit a news item!

    Or perhaps you’ve written a rather ground breaking insight into some aspect of Debian and you feel compelled to share it with others? Knock up a longer editorial article and send it to the editors.

    General feedback should be sent to staff@debianplanet.org

    The place to get help on a Debian problem (after reading docs) or to just chat and chill is #debian on irc.oftc.net.

    Many of the Debian Planet staff live there so pop by and say hello.

    Debian Planet also has its own channel on the same network called #debianplanet.


    Trademark Issues with Debian’s packaging of Mozilla
    Submitted by wolftales on Friday, January 21, 2005 – 23:43
    MozillaI am a little concerned at the discussion I was reading in debian-legal regarding Mozilla trademark issues within Debian provided Mozilla packages. The summary is that Mozilla wants to insure that anyone using a program named Firefox or Thunderbird meets Mozilla’s QA requirements for those trademarked programs. Very understandable. Debian’s “Debian Free Software Guidelines (DFSG)” requires that anything it includes within it’s base distribution be free to distrubte, use and modify. Understandable as well since their goal is a completely Free distribution.

    The problem is, Mozilla is concerned that changes made by Debian(or Debian derivative distros) will not meet Mozilla’s QA requirements, and therefore should not use the Mozilla trademarks. The longer version isn’t so much Debian, but the derivative works based on Debian. Debian has a history of providing quality packages. But Debian’s DFSG allows anyone to pick up Debian and modify it anyway they wish, hence free.

    This may result in Firefox and Thunderbird (and any other Mozilla product) going into non-free, which removes it from the base distribution and further limits distribution, or it will need to be rebranded which will also limit distribution by removing association with Mozilla. I would presonally prefer it go into non-free before it gets renamed to something else.

    Since Debian has a lot of derivative distributions based on it, has the largest centerally supported hardware platform support of any of the distributions and has become the NetBSD of Linux in porting software to the most platforms, I feel it is important that Mozilla products remain in the base distribution as unchanged as possible.

    I do not have a legal background, nor do I have a simple solution to this issue. But I am concerned that if Mozilla remains too restrictive on this front, this could lead to similar problems that Java has becuase of SUN’s control. Ignoring the several competing languages that srung up becuase of the strict regulation on Java. As it stands, Java does not integrate well under Linux becuase of this issue. A lack of QA becuase distributions can not bundle it within their system. This leads to a definite difference in user experience between Windows and Linux. I don’t want to see something similar happen to Mozilla.

    I believe Mozilla should allow Linux distributions to do the work of packaging for them, and find some way to resolve the trademarks issues without effectively renaming or rebranding Mozilla products. This will have the benefit of further integration within those distributions and their environments. The alternative will have a negative impact on the adoption of Mozilla products with in the open-source community and slow down development as Linux distributions will be less likely to be involved with the packaging of the software.

    Mozilla’s goal for 2005 is for further adoption and distribution of Firefox and Thunderbird. Making it difficult for distributions to incorporate them easily will limit that effectiveness.

    Category: News

    Search articles

    ·News (406)
    ·Features (5)
    ·Site News (16)
    ·HOWTOs (79)
    ·Tips (21)
    ·Opinion (29)
    ·Q & A (35)
    ·Sponsorship (1)
    ·Press Releases (5)

    Log in


    Remember me

    » Register
    » New password

    Debian Security Announcements
    DSA-943 perl
    DSA-942 albatross
    DSA-903 unzip
    DSA-941 tuxpaint
    DSA-940 gpdf
    DSA-939 fetchmail
    DSA-938 koffice
    DSA-937 tetex-bin
    DSA-936 libextractor
    DSA-935 libapache2-mod-auth-pgsql

    Planet Debian
    Wouter Verhelst: On flames.
    Joachim Breitner: Fixing my planet.debian.org subscription
    Steve Kemp: She has the blood of reptile just underneath her skin
    Pierre Habouzit: Married …
    Pierre Habouzit: whitelister 0.4 (SPF) and aaege ….
    Pierre Habouzit: kde 3.4.1 upload
    Holger Levsen: In case you are running OpenWRT
    Michael Janssen: Shiny roofs are good for the environment!
    Matthew Palmer: Work it out yourself, dammit!
    Axel Beckert: Tell me which music you like and I tell who you are

    Debian Administration
    How do I prevent rebuilt packages from being upgraded?
    Disabling the print-screen key inside X?
    Monitoring your bandwidth usage with vnstat
    Ruby on Rails on Debian
    Choice for Virtual Private Servers?
    Monitoring your hardware’s temperature
    Sending mail with Exim from ‘dialup’ IP
    How to recover GRUB Debian Sarge after reinstalling Windows
    Getting a GUI
    Spam filtering with Pyzor and SpamBayes

    Latest poll: Which release scheme should Debian follow?
    Continue this way (release when ready)
    Give up on releasing
    Split the release up
    Speed the release up
    Crank the workload up (see DebianWiki ReleaseProposals for details on these)

    Total votes: 372
    0 comments · older polls

    home · archives · news feeds · about · polls · search · sections · user account

    Powered by the amazing Drupal

    Debian Planet is not officially related to the Debian Project.
    Debian and the Debian logo are trademarks of Software in the Public Interest, Inc.